This song is about an untrue rumor regarding Cassie Bernall and the Columbine Massacre on April 20th, 1999. It is said that either Eric Harris or Dylan Klebold, the two shooters, put a gun in her face and asked her "Do you believe in God?" to which she answered 'Yes' and was killed. The truth is that she was hiding during the shootings and praying extremely loudly, thus allowing one of the shooters to find her. Eric Harris put his head below the table under which she was hiding, said "Peek-A-Boo" and killed her with one shot. However, one girl, Valeen Schnurr, was asked if she believed in God, to which she said, " Yes, err, No, it's what my family has taught me to believe." She was then left where she stood by the Harris, unharmed. Rachel Scott was killed by four shots, but it was stated by the fbi that neither Harris nor Klebold killed someone after answering 'yes' to 'Do you believe in God? '